Serenity Test Screening Last Night: The reviews are in and they're raves.

nerd4hire

Certified Uncloneable
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
9,102
Most of the people who saw the test screening of Serenity last night appear to have been fans, but to say they loved it would be understatement.

There's a spoiler-free thread at Whedonesque.com that contains some mini-reviews by members who saw it:

http://whedonesque.com/?comments=5573

Herc from Ain'titCool saw it. A couple of his readers saw it, and they sent in reviews. There may be spoilers here. I don't know. As soon as I saw a sentence beginning that may have contained spoilers, I scrolled quickly down.

http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=18992
 
DarkWorlds' Serenity review

SCOOP: SERENITY advance screening report

An invited test audience watched an advance screening version of SERENITY, the film version of a short-lived and much-lamented science-fiction series, on Tuesday night in Los Angeles. Based on the cheers and applause that began as soon as the lights dimmed, the theater was primarily filled with fans of the series who wanted to be the very first to see their beloved show make the leap to the big screen.

You see, once upon a time, there was a television show called FIREFLY. It followed the adventures of Captain Malcolm Reynolds (Nathan Fillion), a veteran of a war that his side lost, as well as his crew and guests: "companion" Inara Serra (Morena Baccarin), the doctor Simon Tam and his mentally unbalanced sister River (Sean Maher and Summer Glau), engineer Kaylee Frye (Jewel Staite), first officer and fellow veteran Zoà« Warren (Gina Torres) and her husband Wash Warren (Alan Tudyk), who piloted the ship, muscle Jayne Cobb (Adam Baldwin), and the religious man of the bunch, Shepherd Book (Ron Glass).

Mistreated by its network, which aired episodes out of order and put the series in the Friday Night Time Slot of oom, it was unceremoniously dumped in December of 2002 before all fourteen episodes had a chance to air. Thanks to the magic of DVD, fans were finally able to see the entire series. Word spread as new fans discovered the show, and sales exceeded expectations. Thanks to the popularity of the DVD set, the quality of the base material, and the sheer determination of series creator Joss Whedon (of BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER and ANGEL fame), FIREFLY has made the leap to movie-dom. The result is SERENITY, a film slated for release in September of 2005 (it was original set for April, but the studio decided that it would face less competition in the fall), written and directed by Whedon.

The movie is still very much a work in progress; most of the effects are either half-finished or missing, the music was a temporary fill-in, and the titles have not yet been completed. In addition, there were some issues with film quality in sections, and some of the editing remained choppy. There were also a few elements in the set-up that did not seem to completely gel with the information gleaned from the series, and we didn't learn much about what happened in the six months between the series and the film. I wished for more screen time by a few of the characters, but with a primary cast of nine, there is only so much screen time available.

Even with issues such as these, SERENITY is already a very good film. The fact that it was as strong as it is now, so far from the actual release date, is exciting. The story overall is strong and the characters remain as engaging as they were on the series (some more so than expected). Although one of the people running the screening referred to the film as "special-effects driven," it would be far more accurate to call it story-driven. Besides, special-effects driven movies can be seen on any given weekend. It's far more satisfying to focus on plot and interesting characters. Whedon does. That said, I do look forward to the visuals of the finished product, as they should add to the effectiveness of the film.

SERENITY ties more loose ends than I had anticipated (although not all of them that remained from the series), and the film had many surprises and shocks in store. For those of you familiar with Whedon's work, it (unsurprisingly) has his stamp and style all over it. Overall, I laughed, I cried, it was better than CATS. No, really. It was.

If you're looking for a full synopsis and spoilers galore for this new film, you wont find them here. You'll want to head to the theater for SRERENITY and bring a few friends along with you. If you're not familiar with FIREFLY, then buy yourself the four-disc DVD set as a present to yourself this holiday season. This show is worth having in your library even without this feature film to cap it off. Every installment is a strong offering, which is quite an accomplishment for any fledgling series. Don't be dissuaded by its Sci-Fi/Western/Action hybrid nature, because it just plain works. These characters are worth getting to know.

Had the Fox Network shown the pilot first and given sufficient much-deserved support to FIREFLY, we might still be watching this gem every week. As much as I wish this were so, the result of this cancellation tragedy looks to be an amazing and intense film that makes what happened almost worthwhile. SERENITY really will be that good when it hits theaters in September.

- Reported for DARKWORLDS.COM by Amy Berner. Contact Amy at amy_berner@yahoo.com.

Look for the new book FIVE SEASONS OF ANGEL at your favorite bookseller or at http://www.benbellabooks.com, which includes an essay by DARKWORLDS.COM columnist Amy Berner.

Source: http://www.darkworlds.com/ls/art_16627.html
 
Aintitcool Reports On Serenity Screenings

The version of "Serenity" that screened in Chatsworth Tuesday evening isn't quite the movie we'll be seeing next fall. The music was temporary and the special effects were only about half-baked, with Adam Baldwin hanging off wires and many spaceships lurching about without texture and detail.
Still, in many ways the film is already a great antidote for those of us so terrifically bored by the "Star Wars" prequels. The lion's share of my own disappointment with "The Phantom Menace" and "Attack of the Clones" can be traced to an absence of players as compelling and likeable as Han and Leia.
"Serenity," by contrast, returns to "Firefly" fans better than half a dozen Solo-caliber characters, including loutish Jayne, heartsick Kaylee, conflicted Mal, disdainful Inara, heroic Simon and damaged River. In addition, the evil Alliance has dispatched a great new villain, a ruthless and amusingly philosophical self-proclaimed "monster" essayed by Brit Chiwetel Ejiofor.
The new film is smart, romantic, moving, fast-paced, action-packed and, most crucially, one of the funniest films you'll see next year. It's certain to be a must-see for every "Firefly" fan, as it answers every question devotees may have harbored with regard to two important elements of the series: The Reavers and River Tam. (It also offers a bit of resolution with regard to two key shipboard romances.)
But Herc loving a new Joss Whedon project hardly warrents a headline, yes? The better news is that "Serenity" is garnering raves from others who caught the screening, like "The Scientist":
Hey Herc! The Scientist here with a quick review of Serenity, although I suspect that you'll be sending a review as well since I saw you at the screening. I tried to stay impartial throughout the viewing of the movie since I'm an unabashed lover of the show and think that Objects in Space is one of the finest hours to ever air on the small screen. That being said, I'll try to break down my review for two audiences: the newbies and the oldbies.

Non-Firefly viewers: First, if you've never seen the show before, the movie does a fantastic job of establishing all of the characters over again so you don't have to worry about coming in unprepared. Also, the more overt western aspects of the show have been tremendously tamed down, so it plays more straight-forward in a scifi universe, but all without losing the grittiness and rawness that made the worlds on the show so special. It's extremely funny, almost always surprising, and kick-ass. I especially think that those of you who like operatic martial arts films will enjoy the choreographed fights that appear now and then. Just wait until you see the first trailer, cause I'm guessing you'll all flip.

Firefly droolers: Reavers! River and Simon back story! More shocks than you can shake a stick at! You can't take the sky from me! But seriously, when this thing gets through with all the post-prod. stuff, you're going to be peeing in your brown leather coats because it'll be like the clocks were rewound and you were in 2002 again. It's not perfect yet, mind you. I think that Zoe and Book get a little neglected and a couple of the new additions to the 'Verse are weak, but that's nitpicking the absolute blast I had seeing everybody again. Plus, there's some wicked gorram action that would have been way out of budget for the TV show.

The temp tracks and rough cg sometimes detracted from the film and the editing is still rough in spots, but this thing doesn't come out for over 8 months! The only other extremely early preview I've been this excited about was when I was much more wee and saw a super rough cut of Toy Story (Hey! That's another one Joss had his hand in.) Start getting excited everybody, this one's a winner!

The aptly-named "Happily Surprised" adds:
Tonight, in Chatsworth, CA, I think I stumbled across the geek Holy Grail. Upon the announcement of said Holy Grail, cheers erupted from the crowd"¦ For what we were "the first audience ever" to view was"¦ Serenity.

Since this has been the subject of much banter on this site and I'm sure there will be a million of other reviews, I'll skip any other touching stories about the screening. But I will tell you that I am not a hardcore Joss Whedon fan. I've seen a handful of Buffy and Angel episodes (and enjoyed them) and I admire his dedication to his online fanbase, but I've never seen Firefly and I've never totally bowed down to him. No hard feelings, just haven't been so totally familiar with him as to realize his genius.

My bad.

This movie rocked. While it seemed a tad too long, that just means more gold for the DVD. Anyway, I don't even know what they could cut out because just about every scene kept the movie moving along. Before I contradict myself again, I'll just get to the meat.

Whedon has created such incredible characters and dialogue in this movie. What has always struck me about most science fiction movies is that no one speaks normally, it's almost as if space has stifled their sense of normalcy and rammed a giant stick up the characters' asses. Well, as most of you will already know, Whedon can put his characters in the most unimaginable and incredible circumstances and still give them personalities, wit, and true emotion. It doesn't sound like much, but between the dialogue, the characters, and the visuals (effects were unfinished, but you could tell what will be in store for the final product), I believe that he has really not just elevated the genre, but has transcended it.

The characters are as fleshed-out as most Whedon fans would probably expect, but I was not prepared for this. Nathan Fillion (a guy I ashamedly say I only really recognized from Two Guys A Girl and A Pizza Place) is a great addition to the heroes of the big screen. He's the best Han Solo since"¦ well"¦ Han Solo. The rest of the cast, filled with people I kind of recognized, seemed so comfortable and so natural. Their rapport with each other was perfect. It really shows that they all spent time together on a TV show"¦ albeit a short-lived one.

But the best character (and I think she was new to the troupe) was a waifish girl, Fiona Apple look-alike, named River. The story centers around her. She's a mentally unstable psychic who is also a trained killer. The government (here, called The Alliance) has been doing tests on her for years, utilizing her psychic abilities and building her killing skills, until her brother rescues her. This is the set up for the prologue, which blew everyone away. Months later, we see that they've been on-board the Serenity and her brother is being used as an on-board doctor and she is being used for her psychic skills as an asset on their money-grabbing runs. I'm sure someone else will have a more detailed synopsis. As for me, I'm going to boil it down because it wasn't what really impressed me about the movie. Bottom line is that, The Alliance is trying to find her. Led by an assassin (who, of course, was written beautifully and with great complexity), they know that she's on-board Serenity. Despite being tracked by these folks, Fillion and his crew keep her around for her skills, out of curiosity of what she's all about, and because Han Solo has a heart. You see, what makes her so interesting and what kicks ass most about this movie is that, when she whups ass, she whups ass! I'll honestly say that her fight scenes blow away anything I've seen on Buffy, in Kill Bill, or just about anything I've seen in a long time. I found myself hoping for more fight scenes when, much of the time, she was in her crazed psychic state"¦ and then the fight scenes came. Whedon knows what his audience (old fans and, like me, new ones) like.

The final fight, by the way, will not disappoint anybody, if you like air battles, check. Gun fights, check. Attacks by nasty ass villains (the Reavers), check. Hand to hand, check. Swords, check. Battles of wit, check.

The audience was filled with old Whedon fans. And they seemed quite ecstatic about the whole thing. The cheers didn't just erupt at the beginning, they were all throughout. There were actual screams at points. These would break out with little bits of dialogue from familiar characters, after the fight scenes, during space battles, at looks characters would give each other, and, of course, at the end. I'll be happy to drag my uninitiated friends to this when it comes out and I just may feel like I'm a little more on the inside this time around. But no matter"¦ it's a great movie, none of this horseshit Steven Sommers-type popcorn movie, this is a great movie.

Source: http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=18992
 
Here's something interesting. It's a review of the test screening from someone who was not previously a Firefly or Joss Whedon fan.

http://aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=18999

Here's a blurb from it:

I can't and won't say that Serenity was better than Star Wars, because they are way too different for me to compare them. But let me put it this way: All my life I've envied most adults for having had the experience of watching Star Wars in the theater before it was big. To have had that moment of "Oh my god, this is f**king amazing. Oh my god, this is gonna be huge!" Well, frankly I was jealous - until now. I now feel like I've had that kind of experience, and I'll be able to tell my children that I was at the first public screening (after which they will shoot me confused expressions and whisper "daddy's a geek" to each other).

Take note non-Firefly fans. Serenity is going to be a monster hit.

Even if you only like Joss for Buffy and Angel, this is going to affect you.

I can go back to a time before Lord of the Rings became a box office smash. I was an uber-fan of the books for some time before that. I can remember that cult feeling of knowing you were privy to a secret and eternal truth as to the greatness of the work. I can remember trying to convince others of what was to me an immutable fact. Lord of the Rings was great. I can remember being chuckled and P'shawed to the background.

When the movie hit that all changed. Lord of the Rings became mainstream. The same nimrods who laughing at you for loving the book were now lecturing you on the finer points of LOTR (as they now called it).

That same kind of thing will happen when Serenity starts breaking box office records. I warn you. You probably won't like it.

So here's some advice from someone who's been there. Enjoy the cult status of the works of Whedon while you've got it. After September that's all going to change, and I'm not sure you're going to like it.
 
Well you've got until September to tenderize it PG. 🙂

There was buzz before the test screening you know?

Universal obviously thinks they might have a winner. They threw a trilogy clause into the actor's contracts.

As I recall from LOTR though, the buzz didn't really begin until the digital downloads of the preview hit the internet. Sernity's effects haven't been completed yet.

Get ready with the salt and pepper.
 
Back
Top Bottom