Annabelle: Creation (2017) - 5/10
Christ, this was such a chore to get through. For the most part, it was just boring, dragging on, and relying on those idiotic jump scares that the franchise has shied away from in the past. The storyline wasn't nearly interesting enough and the film couldn't figure out which character was the protagonist. It didn't create likable characters the way past films have which meant that you couldn't root for them later because you'd been wishing them dead since the beginning. The ending also went way too far in hammering in the connection to the past Annabelle film and I just felt irritated throughout, waiting for it to end.
However, there were a couple of interesting scenes with genuine scares and the acting wasn't too bad. The way they tied it into the overall universe also worked for me, mostly, so the rating is way better than what it could have been.
The Nun (2018)
I am absolutely not in the mood for this. On top of all the bad reviews I've read, and the spoilers I have, I am right now 20 minutes in and just don't even want to look at the screen. And not for scary reasons. So, I'm going to skip this and move directly on to the next Annabelle film. Maybe someday I'll actually see this all the way through.
Annabelle Comes Home (2019) - 9/10
Phew, so glad to get back to what makes this series so good, another strong outing. Proof that you need the Warrens (even Judy) to make a great Conjuring film 😀
I loved the familiar faces, as well, the actress from the new Jumanji films and an actress from a fan-favorite SPN episode. The focus on a very small amount of characters worked here in a way it didn't in the first Annabelle film and again there were genuine scares again. I also loved that Judy turned out to have inherited her mom's powers, which is something I posed to myself as a possible theory back while watching Conjuring 2.
This is definitely an up and down franchise, but so long as good ones like this keeps coming occasionally, then I'll keep watching.