Twilight

I enjoyed the battle scene, and the wedding could have been even bigger, if they really wanted to milk it.
Agree battle scene was good, I just think it could've been condensed into one film. The film was a whole lot of nothing
and the family gathering allies

They already did milk it, splitting the book over two films. ๐Ÿ˜‰
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
What do you mean the battle scene was good? We didn't get to see the honeymoon.
They already did milk it, splitting the book over two films. ๐Ÿ˜‰

And then there is the current trend of making a lot of films two parters! I can't help but feel this involves a lot of padding.
 
The last book was way thicker than the others though too. I'd argue Eclipse could have been drawn out into two movies as well if they really wanted to. Breaking dawn would have been rushed if it was all in one and we wouldn't have got the bit that makes it better than the book at all!

Thats why I was looking forward to the tv show padding it out even more within the world, but I'm not watching a cartoon. I haven't seen any good twific recs lately, anyone got any? Summer is long here ๐Ÿ™ rainy ice cold fantasy world is a good place to spend it.
 
The last book was way thicker than the others though too. I'd argue Eclipse could have been drawn out into two movies as well if they really wanted to. Breaking dawn would have been rushed if it was all in one and we wouldn't have got the bit that makes it better than the book at all!

Thats why I was looking forward to the tv show padding it out even more within the world, but I'm not watching a cartoon. I haven't seen any good twific recs lately, anyone got any? Summer is long here ๐Ÿ™ rainy ice cold fantasy world is a good place to spend it.
I respectfully disagree. BD may have been thicker, but all they needed to do was add 30 minutes to the film and it would've sufficed. Splitting it into two films, it's padded out and fairly obvious. For those that enjoy it, great. I don't agree with the decision.

Could easily say the same for the final Hunger Games installment, being split in two films.


What are your thoughts on the author saying she'd love the chance to re-write the Twilight series if she could because she's, "a better writer now".
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
What's that BD could have been thicker? I though Bob Dylan was thicker.
Could easily say the same for the final Hunger Games installment, being split in two films.

Then you have The Hobbit. It is a fraction of the size of The Lord of the Rings yet is also a trilogy. Admittedly, a lot of the extra material was events that happened "off-screen" in the novel or in appendices of The Lord of the Rings. However, The Battle of the Five Armies, maybe 10-15 pages of the novel, took up an entire film!
 
hoponlilmama
hoponlilmama
Ah, yes! That's another good example.
What are your thoughts on the author saying she'd love the chance to re-write the Twilight series if she could because she's, "a better writer now".

I think she already tried with Midnight Sun, maybe with Bree Tanner too. Would love to see her write more though, The Host seemed to do ok. I'm not predicting what comes next in the romantasy fandom, but if she captures whichever trend comes after fairies and dragons, she might be on to another winner.

Being the best writer seems to have little to do with the extent of popularity or longevity. It's the tried and true, teen girl fantasy romance, its going to work if you can capture the right audience. Master of the Universe/50 Shades was no where near the best written fanfic out there - but it was by far the most popular and made the most money. I'm still trying to figure out if it is because of the fandom it created and fed week to week soapie style, or if it did simply have mass appeal.

If you're writing for a living, the amount of money made matters more than a literary masterpiece that no one reads.
 
ILLYRIAN
ILLYRIAN
Good point, now if only I could make vast amounts of cash for the drivel I write, I wish they'd publish it!
I think she already tried with Midnight Sun, maybe with Bree Tanner too. Would love to see her write more though, The Host seemed to do ok. I'm not predicting what comes next in the romantasy fandom, but if she captures whichever trend comes after fairies and dragons, she might be on to another winner.

Being the best writer seems to have little to do with the extent of popularity or longevity. It's the tried and true, teen girl fantasy romance, its going to work if you can capture the right audience. Master of the Universe/50 Shades was no where near the best written fanfic out there - but it was by far the most popular and made the most money. I'm still trying to figure out if it is because of the fandom it created and fed week to week soapie style, or if it did simply have mass appeal.

If you're writing for a living, the amount of money made matters more than a literary masterpiece that no one reads.

I agree. If you capture the right market with the right story...
The issue is, whilst her works may be remembered, they may not be taken seriously. I guess she's now too wealthy to care. ๐Ÿ˜‰

I wonder if she had her time over whether SM might have her vampires NOT sparkle.
 
I've seen that Netflix has commissioned 2 series now for Midnight Sun, still animated though and no idea yet who is voicing any of the characters
 
I'm considering a twilight reread, but do I do twilight and midnight sun, then move on the book 2?
 
Back
Top Bottom