What Do You Think Is Overrated On BTVS/AtS?

hoponlilmama

Scooby
Joined
May 8, 2023
Messages
2,506
I guess you could also label this thread 'controversial opinions'. 🤣

Whether it is a character (major or minor), a storyline, relationship, a season, a quote, an episode, or particular scene - what do you think is overrated on BTVS (or AtS)? Love to hear your thoughts!
 
I Will Remember You, The Body, Faith, Once More With Feeling, the Potentials, Spuffy, Lorne, Buffy S3, the Trio, Angel's redemption arc, the First...
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
The First, a monster of the week so utterly boring I cannot even remember it from its own MotW episode.
TheAnnoyingOne
TheAnnoyingOne
I don't think the Potentials, the Trio and the First are overrated though, they got a lot of hate.
Cordelia.
A bully that never really stops being a bully, gets a speedrun to being a ”better person” but only for romance reasons not actual character development, and somehow stays on the shows for 7 years (Btvs 1-Ats4) surviving on snarky one-liners and looking good.

Angel’s final seasons is one of my favorites because we’re finally rid of Cordelia.
 
Spike, obviously. Should have been staked in the Season 4 finale.

I was thinking just that. Though I like Spike as a villain, reluctant ally and anti-hero, he added nothing positive to S5 and was the single biggest negative of S6&7, with Spuffy and replacing Buffy by far as the most important character in the show. S7 was all about Spike.
 
I Will Remember You, The Body, Faith, Once More With Feeling, the Potentials, Spuffy, Lorne, Buffy S3, the Trio, Angel's redemption arc, the First...

I don't think you'll find many supporters of the potentials, the Trio, or The First. 🤣
The rest, I disagree. I think the episodes and characters you listed aren't overrated, but each to their own!
Post automatically merged:

Spike, obviously. Should have been staked in the Season 4 finale.

"Dark Wes". He's not "dark", he's just an asshole who avoids all personal responsibility while wallowing in self-pity and entitlement. Oh, and he has a beard.
I actually laughed out aloud at your last sentence. 🤣
And just on Wes, I think the relationship/dance between Wes and Fred was overrated. I think she had a better connection with Gunn.

As for Spike, as I've said before, that was the time to run him out of town if they didn't want to kill him off. Have him go over to LA and be a reluctant ally to AI.
 
I guess you could also label this thread 'controversial opinions'. 🤣

Whether it is a character (major or minor), a storyline, relationship, a season, a quote, an episode, or particular scene - what do you think is overrated on BTVS (or AtS)? Love to hear your thoughts!
Angel and Spike.
 
Spike, obviously. Should have been staked in the Season 4 finale.
Make that the season 2 finale.

Buffy should've betrayed Spike and had Cordy or Oz waiting outside with the rocket launcher to take out the car with Spike and Dru in it.
 
That would have been a shame. The car looked like a classic.

It would have made a spectacular scene though! And you could easily argue that Spike had already betrayed her by wandering off.
 
N
NoShip
I totally LOVED the car
"Once More, with Feeling". But that's probably because I hate musical episodes (or musical films, for that matter) in general.

AtS is overrated imo. I never managed to care about that show the same way I care about BtVS, I just didn't connect with it. It probably didn't help that I didn't care about Wesley, Cordelia or Gunn (I only liked Lorne and Fred).
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
Lorne and Fred are definitely my two favourites on Angel.
Anyanka Bunny Slayer
Anyanka Bunny Slayer
Angel is A LOT funnier if you live in Los Angeles. So many inside jokes 😄
AlphaFoxtrot
AlphaFoxtrot
Angel is the better show, but yeah, no attachment to the characters.
Angel and Spike.
I'll throw my support behind Spike as I love the character; until we get to about mid-s5 and beyond...
Why do you think Angel is overrated?
Post automatically merged:

"Once More, with Feeling". But that's probably because I hate musical episodes (or musical films, for that matter) in general.

I've always said this about musicals - there is no middle ground. You either like them, or you don't. I happen to love musicals so I love OMWF. They took a big swing though doing the ep, it could've ended badly.
AtS is overrated imo. I never managed to care about that show the same way I care about BtVS, I just didn't connect with it. It probably didn't help that I didn't care about Wesley, Cordelia or Gunn (I only liked Lorne and Fred).
Key factor if you don't like the majority of the characters! Would you have preferred those characters (Cordy and Angel, specifically) remained over on BTVS? Rather than not creating a spin-off at all?
 
I'll throw my support behind Spike as I love the character; until we get to about mid-s5 and beyond...
Why do you think Angel is overrated?
Post automatically merged:



I've always said this about musicals - there is no middle ground. You either like them, or you don't. I happen to love musicals so I love OMWF. They took a big swing though doing the ep, it could've ended badly.

Key factor if you don't like the majority of the characters! Would you have preferred those characters (Cordy and Angel, specifically) remained over on BTVS? Rather than not creating a spin-off at all?
I never cared about Cordelia, even when she was in BtVS, so it didn't really make a difference to me. I always loved Angel, he left a big void, but I did like the idea of him having his own show. I just wish it was done differently, the characters, plots and atmosphere didn't speak to me.
 
I never cared about Cordelia, even when she was in BtVS, so it didn't really make a difference to me. I always loved Angel, he left a big void, but I did like the idea of him having his own show. I just wish it was done differently, the characters, plots and atmosphere didn't speak to me.
That's fair. The series isn't for everyone.
At least you gave it a try and realised it wasn't for you. As mentioned previously, if you don't like or can't connect with a character (or characters, in this case), then you're basically forcing yourself to watch a television program.

If I may ask, you like the idea of the spin-off, which characters do you think should've been included? Other folks from BTVS or completely new faces?
 
That's fair. The series isn't for everyone.
At least you gave it a try and realised it wasn't for you. As mentioned previously, if you don't like or can't connect with a character (or characters, in this case), then you're basically forcing yourself to watch a television program.

If I may ask, you like the idea of the spin-off, which characters do you think should've been included? Other folks from BTVS or completely new faces?
I'd have been fine with new characters instead of Cordelia or Wesley, but there are some old characters that would have been an interesting addition to AtS. Like Oz, Faith or even post-chip Spike (because the chip plot had a lot of potential imo). I know they all appeared on the show, but only Spike became a regular and that was toward the end of the show.

Mr. Trick would have fitted in so well. Instead of wasting the character by having him be killed so quickly, he could have been an important figure of Wolfram & Hart, or an unpredictable gray character siding either with Angel or the enemy, depending on what would benefit him.

Also, Whistler. I know the actor got fired and replaced by Doyle (not sure why), but Whistler's connection to Angel that has been established in BtVS, where it was shown he knew Angel before Buffy became a Slayer and gave him a new purpose, made him an interesting character that I'd have loved to see on AtS.
 
NotASlayer
NotASlayer
I think Whistler's actor was simply unavailable.
I'd have been fine with new characters instead of Cordelia or Wesley, but there are some old characters that would have been an interesting addition to AtS. Like Oz, Faith or even post-chip Spike (because the chip plot had a lot of potential imo). I know they all appeared on the show, but only Spike became a regular and that was toward the end of the show.

Mr. Trick would have fitted in so well. Instead of wasting the character by having him be killed so quickly, he could have been an important figure of Wolfram & Hart, or an unpredictable gray character siding either with Angel or the enemy, depending on what would benefit him.

Also, Whistler. I know the actor got fired and replaced by Doyle (not sure why), but Whistler's connection to Angel that has been established in BtVS, where it was shown he knew Angel before Buffy became a Slayer and gave him a new purpose, made him an interesting character that I'd have loved to see on AtS.
These are all great ideas, I agree! Over the years I've seen a few people also suggest that Oz would've been a great addition on AtS. Could definitely see it happening.

Also think many fans (myself included) would've loved to have Mr. Trick around for longer, so your suggestion is perfect.
 
"Once More, with Feeling". But that's probably because I hate musical episodes (or musical films, for that matter) in general.

AtS is overrated imo. I never managed to care about that show the same way I care about BtVS, I just didn't connect with it. It probably didn't help that I didn't care about Wesley, Cordelia or Gunn (I only liked Lorne and Fred).

I can relate, Angel as a series never connected with me as much as Buffy as a series did. Although I appreciate Angel getting more development beyond 'love interest' as a character a large part of me would have been okay if he had never left Buffy (plus I have to believe if Angel never left Spuffy would have never happened and I consider than ship, and Spike in general, the most overrated thing in the franchise). I never cared much for Wesley either. Gunn could have worked just fine on Buffy I think and it may have meant more. Cordelia...depended on the day.
 
I would like to have seen a pairing of Mr. Trick and Willow as a couple of computer geeks who get into an argument over operating systems and Willow stakes him. They were the only techies on the show, but that doesn't mean they have to be buddies. Or maybe that would have been a good angle - a witch paired up with a vampire.
 
Why do you think Angel is overrated?
Post automatically merged: Yesterday at 5:52
Angel was the obvious love interest, and, while orders of magnitude more enjoyable than Buffy Spike, Buffy Angel was just so obvious and tropey. Also, Angel refusing to help the love of his unlife in S1 and large parts of S2 and S3 just rub me the wrong way. When Xander is more into helping Buffy than Angel, there is a big problem.

Finally, Angel was designed to make the women viewers fall in love with him as shown by the casting directors description of the most gorgeous, beautiful man among men ever for the casting call. And, Boreanaz was hired because he gave several women watching his audition heart palpatations. That little gem is in a you tube interview the casting director gave. And I believe it is in the 'Casting Buffy' DVD Commentary as well.

So, I think Angel should have lived up to his casting hype and the Buffy Angel love story should have been a lot more subtle.
 
Back
Top Bottom